US Appeals Court affirms news reporter has no right to discovery to prove innocence

Stanley Bolten,

Bad news, former news reporter of USWGO Alternative News, Brian D. Hill, had lost his Federal Court Appeal over his fight to get access to his own criminal case discovery evidence necessary to prove actual innocence, and that the U.S. Attorney Office committed “fraud on the court”.

Since Brian is being deprived of true justice, deprived of his Constitutional rights including his right to prove his actual innocence as part of his due process, everybody needs to sign this petition at the White House petition website to stop this madness and get Brian some justice in a corrupt kangaroo court nightmare that has affected Virginia, North Carolina, and other states of the Fourth Circuit of the United States appellate district. Brian needs justice quickly.

I have been notified to check CourtListener and discovered two new documents in Brian’s FOIA lawsuit asking for his criminal case discovery evidence to be able to prove his actual innocence for his Section 2255 Motion under Writ of Habeas Corpus. They even refused to set new case law precedent by making an unpublished opinion, then rubber stamping the Judgment of crooked Federal Judge Jackson L. Kiser stating that Brian has no right to prove his actual innocence because he will never have a Constitutional right under any means to even be allowed access to the discovery evidence to even be able to prove factual innocence. This is in regards to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). The appeal was to challenge the legal opinion and Judgment of Judge Kiser.

What a crooked unconstitutional jerk that Judge Kiser is. I cannot wait for the time when U.S. President Trump appoints a new Judge for the Western District of Virginia, Danville division. Any day when he is ready to retire, good, I hope that Trump can get a good Judge appointed for Danville, Virginia. Hopefully a better Judge that will actually enforce the Constitution of the United States instead of protecting the corrupt crime committing criminal enterprise monopoly of the United States Department of InJustice and the Thuggish Federal Bureau of Investigation. They are all criminals in my book after what they done to my friend Brian, to Donald Trump, and what they have done to other political prisoners. The FBI and DOJ are the Gestapo. They wanted to overthrow Trump and also to continually punish Brian until he goes back to federal prison. They wanted him to commit suicide by their actions and acting as unconcerned that Brian may kill himself if he is permanently blocked from proving his innocence while sitting on the Virginia Sex Offender registry for 25 years over a crime that he did not commit and based on fraudulent evidence that was used to obtain a Grand Jury indictment. None of them will go to prison for the frame up of Brian David Hill, Not one of those bastards will ever pay for their crimes.

Document #70: USCA Memorandum – CourtListener

Document #71: USCA Judgment – CourtListener

“Brian David Hill appeals the district court’s order granting summary judgment to Defendants in Hill’s action seeking relief under the Freedom of Information Act, 5 U.S.C. § 552 (2012). We have reviewed the record and find no reversible error. Accordingly, we affirm for the reasons stated by the district court. Hill v. Exec. Office for U.S. Attorneys, No. 4:17-cv-00027-JLK-RSB (W.D. Va. Feb. 6, 2018).” – Appellate Court decision

No reversible error!!!! No reversible error!!!! What the hell does that mean? A man cannot be allowed Constitutionally to prove his innocence and the Government doesn’t have to follow Ethics Rule 3.8 regarding their obligation to turn over any evidence regarding actual innocence to a criminal defendant. I guess they can violate whatever federal law or rule that they want. They can refuse to give any already-known discovery evidence material that can prove the actual innocence. So the Appellate Court is siding with lawbreakers????? Siding with the corrupt U.S. Department of InJustice thugs? They rather threaten Brian with criminal charges or have him at gunpoint by corrupt U.S. Marshals or Department of Homeland InSecurity rather than admit that he is actually innocent. They have no morals, they don’t have the moral high-ground. They are as criminal as a gangster or a slew of organized bank robbery, but they are above the law, so why should I be so surprised.

It is unclear whether Brian plans to file a Petition for rehearing, or even a Writ of Certiorari. Knowing how persistent he is, he likely will if he wants to snatch victory from the jaws of defeat.

This ruling is very concerning, since his main arguments for the U.S. Court of Appeals was that:

  1. Brian had properly stated under Oath that he was the criminal defendant of the case which the discovery records of his criminal case were sought, according to the FOIA requests faxed to the U.S. Attorney office. That he needed such records to prove his actual innocence and get his life back and off of the registry once proven innocent.
  2. That Brian had been deprived of due process and deprived of effective assistance of Counsel.
  3. That Judge Kiser, the crooked Federal Judge, had threatened Brian with criminal contempt of court charge only by asking for a criminal investigation into the U.S. Attorney Office for blatant and fragrant Obstruction of Justice by covering up or destroying the discovery evidence material to prevent their victim Brian David Hill from proving his actual innocence.
  4. That as a criminal defendant, he should be entitled to get access to his discovery evidence for his criminal court case to prove his actual innocence to be able to succeed in a 2255 Motion without worrying that it will be dismissed over not having enough evidence to prove his innocence while the Government is blocking him from gathering enough evidence to be found actually innocent.

Thus this sets a new legal precedent where criminal defendants who were railroaded and not allowed to prove their actual innocence, will never be allowed to prove their innocence. Where criminal defendants that cannot obtain their entire discovery packet of evidence for their criminal court case will never be allowed to obtain access to that very evidence to prove actual innocence. Thus everything The Innocence Project has done, has now been in vein. Now nobody will ever be allowed in the future to prove actual innocence in Federal Court if they are appointed a corrupt Federal Public Defender that will refuse to prove the actual innocence of their clients.


One thought on “US Appeals Court affirms news reporter has no right to discovery to prove innocence

Add yours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a free website or blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: